Slok: AI Payoff Avoids S&P 493.

Share

Today's market narrative holds a persistent tension: the immense capital flowing into AI versus the still-unproven breadth of its economic return. A prominent voice from within the very firms funding this buildout has now amplified that core skepticism, forcing a reassessment of where genuine value creation currently resides.

Slok: AI Payoff Avoids S&P 493

TL;DR

  • Payoff Dissent: Apollo's chief economist, Torsten Slok, asserts AI has yielded "zero payoff" for corporate America beyond a select few tech giants, a stark note from a major financier.
  • Geopolitical Divide: The US-led Pax Silica alliance is pressing approximately 35 nations to choose between its framework and China's WAICO, hardening global AI supply chain blocs.
  • LLM Deflation: OpenAI and Anthropic have slashed large language model pricing by up to 80% since June, driven largely by the competitive pressure from open-weight alternatives.
  • Energy, Not Chips: Friday's market movements were dominated by crude, not semiconductors, as Houthi strikes pushed WTI to $103 while the chip index stabilized.
  • IPO Watch: Anthropic's public S-1 filing remains absent from EDGAR as the October IPO window narrows, with markets anticipating its release imminently.

Lead Story: Apollo Economist Cites Zero AI Payoff Beyond the Mag 7

The weekend's most trenchant bear case emerged not from a short seller's desk but from within the strategic heart of the AI financing ecosystem. Torsten Slok, chief economist at Apollo Global Management, issued a client note widely circulated Saturday, contending that artificial intelligence has yielded "zero payoff" for corporate America when the outsized performance of a few key players is excluded. This framing introduces a critical counter-narrative from a firm actively enabling the sector's expansion. [[Bloomberg]](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-10-25/ai-provides-zero-payoff-to-s-p-493-outside-tech-apollo-economist-says) [[TechCrunch]](https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/25/ai-delivers-zero-financial-payoff-to-most-companies-according-to-apollo-economist/)

Slok’s analysis delineates the S&P 500 into the "Mag 7" — Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta, Microsoft, Nvidia, and Tesla — and the remaining "S&P 493." His data indicates climbing revenue per worker and robust profit margins solely for the seven, while the 493 show flat trends. He finds "no signs yet of AI boosting productivity growth" across the broader index. The concentration of spend reinforces this view: the top 10% of firms account for 99.5% of model-serving and inference expenditures, 99% of neocloud investment, and over 95% of outlays to OpenAI and Anthropic. [[implicator.ai]](https://www.implicator.ai/ai-payoff-skips-corporate-america-apollo-slok/)

The most quoted takeaway: "The AI story will be decided in the S&P 493, not the Mag 7." The observation carries a sharp irony, given Apollo's reported negotiations to lead a ~$40 billion financing deal for SpaceX's Nvidia chip procurement — a potentially landmark GPU-lease structure. This internal dissonance underscores the present market paradox: undeniable demand for compute infrastructure exists, yet its broad economic dividend remains largely unquantified outside the select few who build it. [[CNBC]](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/10/07/spacex-nvidia-chips-apollo-financing.html)

In Other News

US demands AI allegiance from global partners. The State Department is reportedly pressuring around 35 allied nations to disengage from China's World Artificial Intelligence Cooperation Organization (WAICO), asserting that participation clashes with membership in the American-led Pax Silica initiative. WAICO, launched by Beijing in July with 29 founding members, now directly challenges Pax Silica's ~24 partners. Kazakhstan's unique dual membership highlights the strategic tension, a position the US now seeks to resolve. Fortune suggests this geopolitical maneuvering grants significant leverage to "swing countries" navigating between the competing blocs. [[Fortune]](https://fortune.com/2026/10/25/us-china-rival-ai-blocs-swing-countries-hedging) [[CryptoBriefing]](https://cryptobriefing.com/us-warns-countries-choose-sides-ai-race/)

Grok's "Odyssey" generates muted response. xAI debuted the inaugural seven-minute, 4K episode of its AI-generated Homer's Odyssey adaptation over the weekend, a collaboration between Grok Imagine, Wonder Studios, and director Dev Walker. Elon Musk’s terse quote-post — "Odyssey with Grok Imagine" — partially fulfills his July pledge for a full AI-made feature by year-end. Critical reception was largely unfavorable, citing visual inconsistencies like weightless hair, unnaturally perfect teeth, background pop-in, a homogenous cast, and a general impression of technical polish devoid of emotional depth. [[TechCrunch]](https://techcrunch.com/2026/10/25/grok-releases-the-first-seven-minutes-of-its-ai-generated-odyssey/)

Open-weight models drive LLM price compression. Data scientist Max Woolf published a widely shared analysis attributing the significant LLM price cuts (up to 80% since June) by OpenAI and Anthropic not to altruism, but to the emergent pricing floor established by open-weight models. With DeepSeek's Flash tier already at ~$0.15/$0.60 per million tokens and more open releases anticipated, Woolf argues that proprietary vendors face untenable "unchecked pricing duopoly" conditions. The market, he contends, may already possess sufficient capable supply for most tasks, eroding pricing power even if open endpoints remain a minority of total token volume. [[minimaxir]](https://minimaxir.com/2026/10/cheap-llms/)

X / Social Pulse

Elon Musk leveraged the Grok Odyssey release into a victory lap on his platform, reposting favorable comments while the replies concurrently flagged technical artifacts and a perceived lack of emotional resonance in the AI-generated content.

Terence Tao shared a guest contribution from the Advisory Group on Mathematics and AI, titled "Disadvantages of Designating Mathematicians for AI Output Releases." This piece furthers his established unease regarding the practice of AI labs selecting mathematicians to validate AI-generated proofs, particularly when proofs are "abandoned at an intermediate stage."

Apollo economist Torsten Slok's client note dominated the financial timeline over the weekend. Its distinction between the "Mag 7" and the "S&P 493" was parsed by both bullish and bearish market participants, setting a critical tone ahead of a busy IPO and earnings season.

One to Watch

Anthropic's S-1 filing remains elusive. The anticipated public Form S-1 from Anthropic has yet to appear on SEC EDGAR, despite the company's previously signaled October IPO window rapidly closing. Prior reporting has indicated a Nasdaq listing under "ANT," a valuation ranging from $1.5–2 trillion, and a capital raise of approximately $100 billion. However, these figures and details remain speculative until the official prospectus is filed. The document itself will provide the first transparent view into the company's financial performance, compute commitments, and identified risk factors. A filing is widely expected in the coming days; EDGAR will be the primary monitor at Monday's market open. [[Yahoo Finance]](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/stocks/articles/anthropic-public-1-still-missing-210349323.html)

Quick Hits

  • Oil dictated Friday's close: WTI finished up 3.8% at $103.27, while Brent hit its highest close since April following renewed Houthi strikes targeting Saudi Arabia. [[Yahoo]](https://finance.yahoo.com/markets/articles/tech-selloff-relents-oil-five-103308077.html)
  • Semiconductor index steadied: The Philadelphia Semiconductor Index (SOX) posted a modest 0.44% gain to 10,779.46 on Friday, stabilizing after Thursday's significant chip sector decline.
  • Moonshot's Kimi K3.1 Pro shipped: The 2.8T-parameter MoE model (104B active, 1M context) was released on October 23, with open weights slated for November 4.
  • Mistral Large 4 "Le Chonk" still pending: Mistral's highly anticipated open weights for its Large 4 model remain unreleased, with its Hugging Face repository still showing a late-October ETA.
  • Amazon's idling Nvidia capacity: Reports indicate Amazon holds over $5 billion in Nvidia servers in warehouses, currently inoperable due to insufficient grid power for activation.

On a Sunday marked by quiet markets, the loudest contention came from a skeptic nestled within the very financial apparatus underwriting the industry he now questions. The coming week will serve as a crucial test for this skepticism, with the impending Anthropic prospectus, further Big Tech capital expenditure guidance, and a volatile crude price now emerging as a more immediate systemic concern.

Sources

Lock in. M. mazen@thorterminal.com

Read more